Shelter Island accommodation from AU$137

Find hotels that Aussie travellers love

More than just hotels
Apartments, cabins, holiday rentals and more, plus millions of reviews from Aussie & Kiwi travellers

Flexibility matters
24/7 support, so you can book with confidence

Relax with our Price Promise
Find a lower price on a hotel or package online, before your stay, and we'll refund the difference^

Check hotel availability in Shelter Island

Tonight
Check prices in Shelter Island for tonight, 1 Jun - 2 Jun
Tomorrow night
Check prices in Shelter Island for tomorrow night, 2 Jun - 3 Jun
Next weekend
Check prices in Shelter Island for next weekend, 7 Jun - 9 Jun

Shelter Island stays as unique as you are

Top hotel deals in Shelter Island

Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available properties in Shelter Island
View all properties
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Accommodation In Shelter Island

Want to see the sights? Planning a business trip? Or perhaps you're looking for that perfect romantic getaway. For your next escape, get the hotel you want at a price that’ll put a smile on your face. From city centre conference hotels to charming hideaways, we have you covered. Book accommodation in Shelter Island with us today and get ready to sleep in, eat out and enjoy a holiday your way.

Not sure what you're looking for? Let us help! When you search Shelter Island accommodation, you can filter by budget, star rating or even specific facilities. Hit the clubs, browse the shops or make friends with the locals—there are a number of hotels just a stone's throw from the action. Or do less running around and more indulging when you book a relaxing and revitalising retreat. Maybe a spa treatment is in your future! In the mood for food? Many of our listed hotels feature great bars, cafes and restaurants for laid-back brunching and suppertime feasting. Some also offer a gym or nearby outdoor activities to help burn off those extra calories.

Save time and money by using Wotif to book cheap Shelter Island accommodation. With millions of rooms available, you’ll find exactly the right place to put your feet up. From bargain motels to rooms fit for blue-blooded luxury, child-friendly to pet-friendly (and definitely wallet-friendly), we make booking a hotel reservation simple.

Shelter Island hotels essential information

Accommodation
4,820 hotels
Lowest Price
AU$137
Highest Price
AU$965
Popular hotels
Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex, Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, The Bentley Hotel Southampton, Saybrook Point Resort & Marina, The Atlantic Hotel, Ocean Resort Inn, Sound View Greenport, Montauk Manor

Frequently asked questions

How many days should I spend in Shelter Island?
Stay a handful of days, a few weeks or a month — you do you, boo. Start by working out the sights you want to see and whether you’re all about relaxation or adventure. Your budget will help you decide too. When it’s time to book your Shelter Island hotel and flight, we’re here to make it happen.
Where should a first-time tourist stay in Shelter Island?
If you’ve never had the pleasure of visiting Shelter Island before, make the experience as easy as possible. Stay somewhere central so you’ll be near the major sights, public transport and things like shops, restaurants and convenience stores. Keep an eye out for Shelter Island hotels that are well located and come recommended by other first-time travellers.
How much does a Shelter Island hotel cost?
No need to sweet-talk the hotel manager — our filters will do the job of finding AU$137 cheap accommodation in Shelter Island. Just enter your trip details and refine your search by things like amenities, property class and budget. Oh, and here’s another money-saving tip: Reserve your Shelter Island hotel outside the busiest months of May, June and July when prices are usually higher.
How do I get a cheap hotel in Shelter Island?
Learn how to score cheap hotels in Shelter Island with our insider tips:

  • Try a little midweek magic: Room rates are almost always cheaper from Mondays through to Thursdays.
  • Sign up for a Wotif account: Enjoy exclusive Mates Rates discounts, including 10% or more off select hotels, when you’re logged in to Wotif.
  • Travel during the low season: January, October and December are Shelter Island’s least busy months which means there’ll be lower prices.
  • It’s all about the filters, dear traveller: Use our filter tool to find the type of holiday you’re after, then sort by the lowest price to find the best deal.

What is the best area to stay in Shelter Island?
Menantic Creek and Coecles Harbour are two neighbourhoods that make Shelter Island such an exciting destination. Another area worth considering for your accommodation in Shelter Island is The Heights. But no matter where you want to be, we have properties that’ll be right up your alley. To see all the different Shelter Island hotel locations, click on “View map” at the top of the page.

New reviews! Best hotels in Shelter Island

^Eligibility requirements and conditions apply.